Rotten Tomatoes
Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

My Movie Starring Paul Dano

Play trailer Poster for My Movie Starring Paul Dano 2025 1h 34m Comedy Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
Tomatometer 4 Reviews 98% Popcornmeter 50+ Ratings
Famous actor Paul Dano comes to Herman in a dream, convincing him to make his feature film "Bear Naked Amazonians from Mars." If he meets the deadline, the film will take Best Feature at South by Southwest, making Herman an international celebrity. This irreverent and hilarious tribute to independent filmmaking functions as both a step-by-step guide and a cautionary tale with a farcical bent.

Where to Watch

My Movie Starring Paul Dano

Critics Reviews

View More
Elijah Fischer MovieJawn 16h
My Movie Starring Paul Dano captures the beauty of coming together to create, even if what you create never sees the light of day, in an infectious way. Go to Full Review
Richard Propes TheIndependentCritic.com May 29
3.0/4.0
While My Movie Starring Paul Dano isn't a perfect film, it sure is a perfectly entertaining film. Go to Full Review
Tim Brennan About Boulder May 28
While a lot of films about filmmaking tend to be cynical and arch, this film is unapologetically sweet-natured toward its cast of oddballs and what it takes to get a movie made, whether or not the end result is good. Go to Full Review
Alan Ng Film Threat May 28
7/10
Writer, director, composer, and artist Joe Bartone has poured every ounce of himself into My Movie Starring Paul Dano, and his sincerity is exactly what makes it work. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Lukas Klaus H @RT79604594 1d Every now and then, an indie movie comes along that tries something new. Where most filmmakers fail, Joe Bartone manages to make an exciting darkly humorous take on difficult life lessons work. Clearly blood, sweat and tears went into went into making this film and it shows. In a world where studios dictate what we should watch and like, stacking the ad campaigns and reviews, it's important to remember that indie films like this are where risks are taken and real visions are ventured. Not made for pure profit, but made for telling that personal story that matters. Give this film a shot. You won't regret it. See more Dan S @RT90700936 1d Right from the start, this felt like a unique film. Great energy from a cast who were clearly committed to doing something fun. And fun it was. See more Ben C. @RT68411813 1d Movies like “My Movie Starring Paul Dano” aren’t made much anymore. It’s a film where someone, Joe Bartone & friends, have put to work decades of experience to make something unique. It takes some creative swings and for that, you should watch this movie. See more Mark O @Ohhimark1 1d The movie had some pretty funny moments. The story was a bit disjointed but so was the unhinged characters trying to make a crappy failure of a movie within the movie. Acting realistic from decent to terrible depending on the actor. See more Robert P. @Silverback611 1d ‘My Movie Starring Paul Dano’ is a highly entertaining and often absurd take on the desperation of those willing to do anything for a taste of fame and fortune. Super fun & insightful, you can tell everyone had a blast making this film. Creative storytelling at its best, loaded with wildly imaginative characters (and I mean ‘Characters’) terrific performances, and a truly satisfying conclusion. My advice, definitely check it out… And just lay back and enjoy the ride. See more J C @BetterWheel 1d A relatable topic for anyone who is chasing a dream. I would say a bit over the top, but, honestly, it's actually a bit too close to real life for my taste. I typically watch movies to escape the existential dread of chasing my own dream in my day-to-day life. The story does drag a bit in acts one and two, and I get the whole "movie about a movie being made" aspect, but the handheld shaking can be a bit tough for me at times, almost giving me motion sickness. That being said, I do think the content is solid and worth a watch. It really comes together in the third act, and as far as movies go, in my 50 years on earth, I have wasted time watching far worse movies than this. Far worse movies that probably cost the annual operating budget of a mid-size town to create, so that being said, I appreciate what the filmmakers have done with a literal shoestring budget. I really hope they get to play with real money someday. I'm certain they could crush it with solid financial backing. See more Read all reviews
My Movie Starring Paul Dano

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Movie Info

Synopsis Famous actor Paul Dano comes to Herman in a dream, convincing him to make his feature film "Bear Naked Amazonians from Mars." If he meets the deadline, the film will take Best Feature at South by Southwest, making Herman an international celebrity. This irreverent and hilarious tribute to independent filmmaking functions as both a step-by-step guide and a cautionary tale with a farcical bent.
Director
Joe Bartone
Producer
Joe Bartone
Screenwriter
Joe Bartone
Distributor
BayView Entertainment
Production Co
Small Factory
Genre
Comedy
Original Language
English
Release Date (Streaming)
May 26, 2026
Runtime
1h 34m