Padre Pio

Audience Reviews

View More

Bryan M @thecivilwargeek Jun 28, 2026 I was gifted a physical copy of this movie as I heard of Padre Pio and wanted to learn more about this Catholic saint. If your goal is similar to mine, then skip this snooze fest. The focal point of this post-World War I story is primarily centered on a battle between capitalism and socialism, as impoverished veterans return from the war to their small Italian town and seek to introduce socialist policies to combat the ruthlessness of wealthy landowners. Padre Pio arrives to this town in a background story, but the two plots never connect. We see Padre Pio heal a crippled man and fight his own personal spiritual demons, but he is in no way connected to the bloodshed that befalls the town. This film is a mess. What little we see of Shia LaBoeuf’s title character is not very revealing, and LaBoeuf, as fine of an actor as he is, isn’t given much to work with here. A truly disappointing film and worthy of the one star only. See more

former C @RT73889332 May 26, 2026 A poor excuse of a film with the name of Padre Pio as a lure for the unsuspecting viewer to watch what turns out to be an homage to Socialism. I was tempted to write a paean to Socialism, but this dreary item is too dark with its loathing of life to be called joyful. The muzak that runs through its entirety was like a hornet continuously trying to land on one’s person. One suspects the perpetrators of this nightmare film may have been infected by Satan himself. One gets disconnected snippets of Padre Pio with nothing leading one to understand what they were about unless one had foreknowledge of his life, but these are only brief glances to justify the name of the movie. There is no historical background about what was happening in Italy to give context, no cultural context, so the actors come across as zombies in black, not a single redeeming joy in their lives, and where is their connection to Pio? A genuine expository Padre Pio movie that is actually about him has yet to be made. See more

Bob M @BobbyGoBoom Apr 20, 2026 I am a Catholic and I went into this with some apprehension considering the reviews. Totally unfounded and I strongly suspect reviews being disingenuous. The movie was beautiful and the depiction of Padre Pio was absolutely powerful and to my knowledge extremely accurate. The visions, the demonic attacks, the bilocation, the stigmata, the reading of souls, etc, etc. part of the movie depicts the rising communist movement and it does so tastefully without being cartoonish. The shots are beautifully artistic and done really well. Bravo. See more

James S @RT85214260 Oct 26, 2025 Honestly as a Christian and a film maker of 10 years I completely feel like this movie failed itself, the story was odd and disconnect, the mystery behind Pio was never revealed nor the link between his church and the other story going on with socialism, terrible writing and communication of a story , and shaking a camera doesnt make your movie grittier or more real just stop, terrible. Disappointed they wasted shia’s talent on a none story See more

Terry D @RT75242982 Aug 16, 2025 A beautiful movie start to finish See more

Jennifer M @RT29798547 Jul 14, 2025 More about the socialist party issues than Padre Pio. Very disappointing ! See more

Read all reviews

Padre Pio

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING